June 2nd, 2025
by Morgan A. Mitchell
by Morgan A. Mitchell
Be aware that there is a significant difference between the reviews and recommendations on this blog. Just because I review a book, TV show, or movie does not mean I recommend it. I am simply analyzing the work and giving my honest opinion of it, as well as providing key points such as the plot summary, age appropriateness (if the reader should choose to read or watch it), and anything else that's noteworthy.
I recently discovered Katherine Reay's book Lizzy & Jane and it's stuck with me. While it's different than her beloved debut Dear Mr. Knightley, it's still loved by many. If you enjoyed Dear Mr. Knightley, then you will love this book!
Plot Summary
Chef Elizabeth Hughes poured herself into her culinary skills and restaurant. But now she's burnt out and worse, her beloved restaurant is starting to suffer. When her older sister Jane is diagnosed with breast cancer, she takes a few weeks off to help her during chemotherapy. The tension that has existed between the sisters since their mother lost her battle with cancer explodes and each must face the conflict that arose during that time.
Meanwhile, Elizabeth finds a way to use her cooking skills for Jane and other cancer patients. While she dates a single dad named Nick, mends her relationship with Jane, and discovers joy in life again, the clock ticks closer to when she has to leave again. Will she choose to go back to her dream or embrace the new life she's found?
Meanwhile, Elizabeth finds a way to use her cooking skills for Jane and other cancer patients. While she dates a single dad named Nick, mends her relationship with Jane, and discovers joy in life again, the clock ticks closer to when she has to leave again. Will she choose to go back to her dream or embrace the new life she's found?
Pros and Cons
This is a gripping book, though some might find it too slow.
Nick has a son from a one-night stand. Also, there are details about chemotherapy and the side effects from it. While it's not graphic, those who get squeamish about medical details might want to skim some sections.
Nick has a son from a one-night stand. Also, there are details about chemotherapy and the side effects from it. While it's not graphic, those who get squeamish about medical details might want to skim some sections.
Personal Thoughts
I never understood what people meant by "emotional fiction" until I encountered Katherine Reay's books. While Lizzy & Jane was a little slow in the beginning, it was worth it. Elizabeth's struggles were real and I'm afraid I ignored my family for the entire day because I was so engrossed. The romantic subplot was sweet and I loved Nick and Matt! I keep going back and reading over Nick's letter to Elizabeth (Persuasion lovers, you will adore this part!). While I was aware that chemotherapy is difficult, I wasn't aware of what it entailed and this book opened my eyes to it.

Notes
Best for teens and adults.
For those of you who have read Lizzy & Jane, what did you think of it? For those of you who have not read it, would you? Tell me in the comments below!
Recent
Archive
2025
February
March
April
2024
January
March
April
May
June
July
August
September
October
November
2023
January
April
Categories
Tags
Abundant Living
Book Review
Books for Adults
Books for Older Teenagers
Books
Christian Heroes
Christianity
Christmas
Devotionals for Adults
Devotionals for Young People
Devotionals
Easter Books
Easter
Encouragement
Faith
Family Friendly
Fantasy Books
Fantasy book series
Fantasy
Fiction
Hard Times
Hope during trials
How-To
Missionary
Movie Review
Movies
Movie
Music
Salvation
Songs
TV Shows
1 Comment
I haven’t read Lizzy & Jane but it’s on my TBR list. I loved Dear Mr. Knightley and look forward to reading more of Reay’s books. I will most likely love the letter because I’m a big fan of Persuasion! ?